• Calcium Q & A • calcium supplements • choices in calcium • calcium-rich foods •
In regards to
which form of calcium supplement is best, It
makes little practical difference, as long as
you take enough. Read the labels: check the
milligrams of "elemental calcium" you're
getting per pill, not the amount of calcium
gluconate, for instance, or calcium citrate. No
pill is pure calcium. The mineral has to be
combined with something else: carbonate,
citrate, gluconate, etc. Plain calcium
carbonate, as found in some antacids, is most
common and least expensive, and contains the
highest concentration of calcium per pill. Thus,
to get a given amount of calcium, you can take
smaller pills, or fewer of them. Recommendations
for how much calcium you need are in terms of
elemental calcium, so read labels carefully to
make sure that you are getting what is
recommended.
How do I choose a calcium
supplement?
- A
USP (United States Pharmacopeia)
symbol means that the calcium
supplement is pure from lead and
other metals. The application
for the USP symbol is voluntary
so many acceptable products do
not display this symbol.
According to a recent laboratory
analysis, calcium supplements,
in the dosage prescribed for
prevention and treatment of
osteoporosis, contain much less
than the safe level of lead. A
further safeguard is that lead
in calcium supplements will not
be well absorbed because calcium
blocks lead absorption.
-
Calcium must dissolve in your
stomach before it can be
absorbed in your intestines and
then used by your body. A USP
symbol on the label of a calcium
supplement means that is it will
dissolve in your stomach. If
your supplement does not have a
USP symbol, you can easily test
it to find out if it will
dissolve. Simply put the
supplement into a glass of clear
vinegar. This creates an acidic
environment much like that of
your stomach. Stir the solution
occasionally. If the calcium
supplement disintegrates within
30 minutes, it should dissolve
in your stomach, too. If the
supplement does not completely
dissolve, choose an alternative
calcium supplement. Be sure to
discard the calcium/vinegar
solution after the test.
- If
you are taking acid blockers for
indigestion, reflux or other
gastrointestinal conditions,
your body may use calcium
citrate better than other
calcium compounds. Acid blockers
reduce the acid in your
gastrointestinal tract that is
usually required for calcium
absorption. However, unlike
other calcium compounds, calcium
citrate does not require an acid
environment for calcium
absorption.
-
Read the supplement label to
find out the calcium content in
milligrams (mg) per serving. The
label may refer to the calcium
as elemental calcium. This
distinguishes the weight (mg) of
calcium alone from the weight
(mg) of the calcium compound
(such as calcium carbonate,
calcium citrate, calcium
phosphate, or others). It is
also important for you to check
the serving size to find out how
many tablets or capsules provide
a specific amount of calcium.
-
Although vitamin D is readily
available in combination with
calcium supplements,
supplemental vitamin D should
only be taken when your daily
requirement for vitamin D is not
met. If you are over 70 or a
homebound individual, you should
discuss your risk of vitamin D
deficiency with your doctor. For
more information, see
"Vitamin D and Bone Health".
-
Magnesium supplements are not
required for most healthy
individuals. Magnesium is
plentiful in a healthy,
well-balanced diet. However,
certain individuals may be at
risk for magnesium deficiency
including those with
gastrointestinal diseases that
cause poor absorption or
increased losses of magnesium,
frail elderly individuals eating
poor diets, alcoholics,
individuals receiving
chemotherapy and those taking
high dose diuretics (water
pills) that deplete magnesium.
Magnesium deficiency is easily
diagnosed by a simple blood
test. Your medical professional
will prescribe a magnesium
supplement if it is necessary or
if you have a disease or
condition that causes magnesium
deficiency.
- A
well-balanced diet following the
food-pyramid approach to good
nutrition including adequate
calcium and vitamin D is what
you need to achieve and maintain
healthy bones. For most healthy
individuals, additional vitamins
or minerals (such as magnesium,
boron, vitamin K, selenium or
others) in the form of
supplements are not required for
bone health. In fact, many of
these nutrients will be present
in a diet with five or more
servings of fruits and
vegetables a day.
Calcium
carbonate provides forty percent elemental
calcium, meaning that a 1,250mg of calcium
carbonate yields 500mg of elemental calcium.
Advantages of calcium carbonate are that it has
the highest percentage of elemental calcium and
it has a track record of effectiveness. It is
best taken with meals to be properly absorbed.
A disadvantage can be that for some individuals
calcium carbonate may cause constipation or gas
Here are some formulations of calcium carbonate:
Name |
Type |
Strength per tab (in mgs) |
Elemental Calcium (in mgs) |
Alka-Mints |
calcium carbonate |
850 mg |
340 mg |
Caltrate |
calcium carbonate |
1500 mg |
600 mg |
OsCal |
calcium carbonate |
625 or 1250 mg |
250 or 500 mg |
Rolaids |
calcium carbonate |
550 mg |
220 mg |
Titralac Tablets |
calcium carbonate |
420 mg |
168 mg |
Titralac Liquid |
calcium carbonate |
1000 mg |
400 mg |
Tums and Tums E-X |
calcium carbonate |
500 or 750 mg |
200 or 300 mg |
Tums Ultra and Tums
500 |
calcium carbonate |
1000 or 1250 mg |
400 or 500 mg |
Calcium citrate provides twenty
one percent elemental calcium. Studies using
calcium citrate show that it is an easily
absorbed calcium supplement. It can be taken at
any time without regard to food. The
disadvantages are that it has a relatively lower
percent of elemental calcium than calcium
carbonate, therefore, you have to take more
tablets of it to equal the same amount of
elemental calcium in calcium carbonate.
Name |
Type |
Strength per tab |
Elemental Calcium |
Citracal Liquidtabs |
calcium citrate |
2376 mg |
500 mg |
Citracal |
calcium citrate |
950 mg |
200 mg |
Citracal Caplets + D |
calcium citrate |
1500 mg |
315 + 200 I.U.
vitamin D3 |
Tribasic calcium phosphate
provides thirty nine percent elemental calcium.
It also is an easily dissolved and well-absorbed
supplement that should not cause gas or
constipation. It can be taken anytime. Calcium
phosphate is the formulation used in specially
calcium fortified orange juice, soy milk, and
rice milk available.
Name |
Type |
Strength per tab |
Elemental Calcium |
Posture |
calcium phosphate |
1500 mg |
600 mg |
Posture-D |
calcium phosphate |
1500 mg |
600 mg + 125 I.U.
vitamin D |
- The term
elemental calcium refers to
the amount of calcium in a product. Many calcium
supplements list the amount of calcium, or
elemental calcium, on the label. But some brands
list only the total weight of each tablet, not
the actual amount of calcium. If you know the
type of calcium compound (check the label), you
can calculate the amount of calcium in the
product using the following formulas.
type of calcium supplement
percentage of calcium |
multiply the weight of the capsule
by |
Example |
Calcium Carbonate
(40 percent) |
0.4 |
500 mg calcium carbonate x
0.4 =
200 mg calcium |
Calcium Citrate
(21 percent) |
0.21 |
950 mg calcium citrate x
0.21=
200 mg calcium |
Calcium Lactate
(13 percent) |
0.13 |
1,550mg calcium lactate x
0.013=
200mg calcium |
Calcium Gluconate
(9 percent) |
0.09 |
2,200mg calcium gluconate x
0.09 =
200mg calcium |
How do I take my calcium supplement?
- It is important to read
supplement labels and follow the
directions for use.
- When your calcium supplement
is well absorbed, your body can
easily use it. For best
absorption, most calcium
supplements should be taken with
food. Calcium citrate is an
exception; it can be taken with
or without food.
- It is best to spread out the
calcium you consume from diet
and/or supplements throughout
the day. In fact, for best
absorption, it is recommended to
consume 500mg of calcium or less
at one time.
Are there any special
considerations?
- If your medical professional
recommends an iron supplement
and you are also taking a
calcium supplement, it is
important that your body absorbs
both nutrients. For the best
absorption of both iron and
calcium, it is recommended to
take your calcium supplement 2
hours before or after your iron
supplement. You should not take
them at the same time.
- Calcium interferes with the
body's ability to use certain
antibiotics, tetracycline for
example. If your doctor
prescribes tetracycline, it is
important for you to take it
properly. Therefore, you should
not take calcium supplements (or
eat calcium-rich foods) at the
same time as tetracycline. Your
antibiotic will work best if you
take your calcium supplement (or
eat calcium-rich foods) 2 hours
before or after taking
tetracycline. It is always
important to speak to your
pharmacist about the proper way
to take your medication.
- Some people who take calcium
supplements complain about
constipation. The best way to
prevent constipation, is to eat
more fiber in your diet from
fruits, vegetables, and whole
grain products as well as to
drink 6 to 8 glasses of water
each day. If these simple steps
are not helpful enough, take a
closer look at your diet to try
to get more calcium from foods
and less from supplements. Read
the label for the amount of
calcium in each dose. A lower
dose calcium supplement may be
better tolerated than a high
dose supplement. In general,
calcium carbonate has the
highest amount of calcium per
dose. Calcium citrate has less
calcium per dose and calcium
gluconate is one of the lowest
dose options.
Absorbability
Most brand name calcium products are
absorbed easily in the body. If the product
information does not state that it is
absorbable, how well a tablet dissolves can be
determined by placing it in a small amount of
warm water for 30 minutes, stirring it
occasionally. If it hasn’t dissolved within this
time it probably will not dissolve in the
stomach. Chewable and liquid calcium supplements
dissolve well because they are broken down
before they enter the stomach.
It's best to take most calcium supplements
with meals. The acid secreted by the stomach
during digestion enhances absorption of most
calcium supplements, especially calcium
carbonate. And the presence of other nutrients
may also promote absorption. Calcium citrate is
an exception: it doesn't need stomach acid to be
absorbed, so you can take it any time (this
makes it good for people who have disorders in
which the stomach produces less acid).
Calcium, whether from the diet or
supplements, is absorbed best by the body when
it is taken several times a day in amounts of
500 mg or less, but taking it all at once is
better than not taking it at all. Calcium
carbonate is absorbed best when taken with food.
Calcium citrate can be taken any time.
Calcium Interactions
It is important to talk with a
physician or pharmacist about possible
interactions between prescription or
over-the-counter medications and calcium
supplements. For example, calcium supplements
also may reduce the absorption of the antibiotic
tetracycline. Calcium also interferes with iron
absorption, so a calcium supplement should not
be taken at the same time as an iron supplement.
The exception to this is when the iron
supplement is taken with vitamin C or calcium
citrate. Any medication to be taken on an empty
stomach should not be taken with calcium
supplements.
Combination Products
Calcium supplements are available in
a dazzling array of combinations with vitamins
and other minerals. While vitamin D is necessary
for the absorption of calcium, it is not
necessary that it be in the calcium supplement
(see winter 1998 issue of Osteoporosis Report
for information on vitamin D). Minerals such as
magnesium and phosphorus also are important, but
usually are obtained through food or
multivitamins. Most experts recommend that
nutrients come from a balanced diet, with
multivitamins used to supplement dietary
deficiencies.
Most published studies show that low calcium
intake is associated with low bone mass, rapid
bone loss and high fracture rates. Adequate
calcium intake will help ensure that calcium
deficiency is not contributing to a weakening of
the skeleton; however, this is only one of the
steps necessary for bone health. A high calcium
intake will not protect a person against bone
loss caused by estrogen deficiency, physical
inactivity, smoking, alcohol abuse or various
medical disorders or treatments.
|